Frontline vs Advantage is a battle that comes up all the time when people are shopping for pet flea treatments for dogs & cats. Frontline and Advantage have both been around the the longest time and are therefore the most well known flea medications. Although these 2 products are often grouped into the same category, they do have differences.
To be clear the 2 products we are comparing in this report are Frontline Plus and Advantage II. There are variants of these product such as Frontline top spot and Advantage Multi (Advocate).
Frontline Plus treats for all flea stages in the pet's surroundings including flea eggs and flea allergy dermatitis. It controls sarcoptic mange and lice. It also treats for paralysis ticks and brown dog ticks for 2 weeks. Advantage will kill fleas, kill flea larvae, control flea allergy dermatitis and control lice.
Frontline Plus contains fipronil and methoprene. Advantage contains IMIDACLOPRID.
Frontline Plus can be used on puppies & kittens from 8 weeks of age. Advantage can be used on puppies & kittens from 6 weeks of age.
Frontline and Advantage both come as liquid form in a tube that is placed on the back of the dogs neck and will treat fleas for 1 month at a time. They are both water resistant for 1 month after 24-48 hours of application.
Frontline Plus comes in 5 different weight ranges; Cats in a green packet, dogs up to 10kgs in a orange packet, dogs 10-20kgs in a blue packet, dogs 20-40kgs in a purple packet and dogs 40-60kgs in a red packet.
Advantage comes in 6 different weight ranges; cats up to 10lbs (up to 4kgs) in a orange packet, cats over 10lbs (over 4kgs) in a purple packet, dogs up to 10lbs (up to 4kgs) in a green packet, dogs 11-20lbs (4-10kgs) in a teal packet, dogs 21-55lbs (10-25kgs) in a red packet and dogs over 55lbs (over 25kgs) in a blue packet.
You can buy Frontline Plus in 3 packs (3 month supply), 6 packs (6 month supply) and 12 packs (12 month supply). Advantage can be purchased in 4 packs (4 month supply), 6 packs (6 month supply) and 12 packs (12 month supply).
Advantage is slightly cheaper than Frontline Plus. Frontline Plus does treat for ticks as well as fleas, so you would expect to pay slightly more for that.
Frontline Plus vs Advantage? who is the overall winner? well overall Frontline Plus looks better on paper BUT.... Advantage seems to be more effective in how well it actually works to treat for fleas. If you need to treat for fleas & ticks then Frontline Plus for dogs is the best way to go. If you just need to treat for fleas, using Advantage for dogs would be best. Every situation is different, so you need to decide what will suit you and your dog best. We hope that this product comparison will help you better decide which direction to go in.
Compare Advantage vs Frontline Plus below in this detailed chart with what each product does
|Component||Advantage for Dogs||Frontline Plus for Dogs|
|Flea Allergy Dermatitis||Yes||Yes|
Please note: These products are only available to Australian customers.